The latest craze in state government has been to suggest raising the sales tax on tobacco products to help with two issues:
1. Help reduce smoking.
2. Create revenue to support state services.
That all sounds great but lets take a closer look at both of these issues.
Help Reduce Smoking
It sounds great. Increase the cost of cigarettes and people will smoke less. But if smoking is so bad why would you even allow it at all. Wouldn't it be smarter to make smoking illegal? Sure that's a pipe dream, but the states could at least make smoking in public places illegal. Anything to reduce smoking and improve peoples health is a good thing. The tax is just a small part of it.
Create Revenue
This is the real reason for the increased taxes. The state governments have found a group of citizens that they can turn into pariahs, and thus taxing them is totally acceptable to the rest of society. Great but no one looks at the reality of this tax grab. The money from the taxes are used for any number of state services. One state wants to use it to provide health insurance to uninsured children, a very worthy cause. They even have an estimate of the expected revenues for the next four years. So of course they are going to plan on collecting every cent of that money and include it in the budget.
But what if the tax increase is enough to actually get people to quit smoking?? What happens then? Well the expected revenue stream starts to slow down. That means less money being collected than planned on. Where does that leave all those other state services that were getting funding from a tobacco tax? UNDER FUNDED is where it leaves them.
Robbing Peter to Pay Paul
This is just the standard in government funding. Gas taxes don't cover the cost of road work, property taxes don't cover the cost of your local services, if they did we wouldn't have sales tax and income tax in our states.
State governments have played this game for too long. They need to look a lot deeper into what they are planning. Sure it sounds good to increase tobacco taxes. And if tax helps in reducing smoking great, but when you tie other services into getting funded by a tax that if it works is meant to reduce the activity that produces the taxes you are going to get these funding shortfalls.
If the government truly believes they are doing this to reduce smoking then they can't in good faith tie the funding of essential services to a revenue stream that is created with the expectation of going away.
It's easy to pick on smokers but it isn't really good accounting.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment